The problems with Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows began with the poster prominently displayed outside the theatre, featuring the protagonist grasping a revolver. This is a misunderstanding that envelops the entire film, substituting explosions, MMA and cross-dressing for the thoughtful detective work of the novels. The film looks fantastic and brings Europe at the turn of the twentieth century to live but neglects to do likewise for the titular character. Unfortunately, the eccentricities of Sherlock Holmes are exaggerated far too much by Robert Downey and he is made to be a comedic figure. While Arthur Conan Doyle created a …
The Debt
Sometimes, a non-linear storyline serves a purpose. It can unravel a mystery piece by piece and keep the audience guessing. Sometimes, it just appears contrived. In The Debt, the non-linear storyline revealed how a trio of ex-Mossad agents had been living a lie since a seemingly high-profile arrest of a Nazi war criminal. The narrative gimmick also caused the film to drag, separating a clichéd spy story from a more interesting drama. The cast who portrays the characters in the current day are compelling, although barely featured. One of the premises of the film is that the lies told by …
Super 8
J.J. Abrams (the writer) – like Gene Roddenberry and Stanley Kubrick – uses the science fiction genre as a medium to showcase how humans can better understand each other and their emotions. The trailer for Super 8 features a spectacular train wreck and although that scene is the most violent of the entire film, it is more harmless and generic than it is spectacular. The extra-terrestrial on the loose in the small Ohio town is a textbook example of a MacGuffin and although its true nature is slowly revealed throughout the film, it still receives far too much camera time. Like …
Sherlock Holmes
To consider the latest Sherlock Holmes film canonical enrages the mind and inflames the soul. Robert Downey Jr. proves to be perhaps the most accurate interpretation of the literary hero but the plot is daft and dilettante. The sophistication and subtlety of Conan Doyle’s short stories are butchered by scenes of excessive violence and bludgeoned by overt symbolism. The atmosphere and setting of the film are sensation. London’s dark side, seen through Holmes Bohemian eyes is spellbinding and the soundtrack suits the action perfectly (the story about the “broken” piano is also fascinating). I could easily enjoy several films in …