Concert films are difficult to evaluate because they are similar to the television broadcast of a sports event. The entertainment value of the event is closely tied to the event itself. If a director misses a shot and the viewer misses part of the action, the mistake is recognized but excellent performance is rarely acknowledged.
The Neil Young Trunk Show rocks but does it rock because Neil Young rocks or because it is an amazing film? Neil Young certainly rocks, combining acoustic and rock numbers. There are passionate lyrics, intricate solos, and a diverse selection of songs. Anyone could have shot this concert with a series of extreme close-up and created a rollicking work.
Jonathan Demme directed two of the best films of the 1990s but has kept a low profile since. His partnership with Neil Young over the course of three films is curious (this was the second documentary). He shone a light on the backstage area at Neil Young shows at the Tower Theatre near Philadephia, informing viewers of how Young gets ready by showing details such as the artist taking care of a hand worn by playing the guitar.
Demme showcases Young’s passion using tight shots. It is very interesting how the lights shine through Young’s long grey hair as he takes great care in his performance, focusing on the instruments as he performs. The grainy texture of the film suits his timeless qualities. The songs are recognizable but there are new numbers and vibrant variations. It’s a great concert – which makes for a great film – but I think most of the credit belongs to the performer, with some given to the director who puts him in the spotlight again. ****